|
Category: Computers & Technology : Internet and Websites
French statesman, Jean Baptise Colbert (1619-1683) once said: "the art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to obtain the largest amount of feathers with the least amount of hissing." And, the ongoing debate over electronic commerce taxation is causing more than its fair share of hissing. Digital commerce activity monitor BizRate.com polled over 3,500 online consumers to measure the impact of e-commerce taxation. The poll, which was taken during the summer of 1999, showed split results. Over 37 percent of the respondents said they would not have made their purchases online if sales tax had been included. Another 37 percent said they would have, while 26 percent said they did not know if they would have purchased the item online if tax had been included.
E-commerce taxation could mean growing pains
According to Datamonitor, industry analyst experts, sales over the Internet will grow to $200 billion by the year 2001. However, the rate of growth of online spending per person is declining even though total online retail spending is increasing, according to a study conducted by The Wharton School of Business. The study also found there is a significant dropout rate among online shoppers, and 15 percent of online buyers from 1997 did not buy online in 1998. "No matter how well electronic retailers have done this holiday season, there are some fundamental factors that appear to be eroding the growth of spending and growth of the market," said Jerry Lohse, research director of the Wharton Forum on Electronic Commerce. "Only 50 percent of the dropouts from 1998 returned to make purchases in 1999. Further, new buyers are not arriving as quickly to take their place," Lohse continued. "The implication is that online shopping is just another way of shopping. According to the study, concerns about privacy and trust were among the most important factors that distinguished buyers from non-buyers online.
Who is liable?
So, what is all this hype about taxing online shopping? In October 1998, The Internet Tax Freedom Act was signed as public law. The Act was based on the simple principle that information should not be taxed. In addition, a commission was established to study electronic commerce tax issues on whether electronic commerce should be taxed, and if so, how it can taxed in a manner that ensures that such commerce won't be subject to special, multiple, or discriminatory taxes. State and local offices were given a prominent voice on the commission. However, Congress retains full authority to change or discard the Commission's proposals. There is also a sense of Congress that there should not be any federal taxes on Internet access or electronic commerce. Virginia Gov, James Gilmore III, is the chairman of the commission, has been appointed the daunting task of advising Congress on the taxation of electronic commerce. The moratorium for taxes is for three years which according to Gilmore was set up so that the Internet would have enough time to grow and that the commission would have enough time to come up with an acceptable public policy with respect to taxation on the Internet. The Commission is expected to issue its recommendations to Congress in April of this year.
State and local governments say yes to e-commerce taxation
It seems that state and local governments are very much for taxing electronic commerce but the problem is that sales, use and income tax based on physical location and property are difficult to apply to the Internet. According to 15 U.S.C. section 381, a state may not collect income tax from a business that merely solicits orders in that same state. Before a state may impose a tax, there must be some connection between the taxpayer or the taxpayer's activities and the state that is sufficient enough to allow the state to exercise jurisdiction over their person (commonly referred to as a nexus). While the required nexus is similar to grounds for personal jurisdiction, sales and use tax often require that a person or business be physically present in the state be fore such a tax can be imposed. According to a report issued by Ernst&Young, many state and local officials fear that the e-commerce boom will lead to erosion of the state and local retail sales and tax base, while e-retailers want to avoid the administrative cost of implementing various regional and local tax rate systems.
According to David Hardesty, vice president of Markle Stuckey Hardesty and Bott, a San Francisco and Larkspur, CA based CPA firm, and contributing author to E-Commerce Tax News sees several problems associated with taxation of e-commerce. "A vendor operating out of a bedroom does not have the staff to deal with the tax rules of over 30,000 state and local authorities in the USA and an untold number of foreign tax authorities," says Hardesty. Another problem says Hardesty is the proliferation of digital products. (When a product, such as software, can be delivered electronically there is no need to know the location of the buyer to complete a transaction. The seller only needs a credit card number). Hardesty says that vendors must make an effort to gather information that is needed for tax compliance when the vendor sells digital products in states where those products are subject to sales and use tax.
Whatever the issues are with taxing or not taxing e-commerce sales, there are pros and cons for each. What effect taxation will have on e-commerce sites is yet to be determined. However, Congress has its hands filled with these issues and will soon let everyone know what the verdict is.
Sidebar (Online e-tailing for 1999)
As the 1999 holiday buying season approached, online buying expectations were at an all-time high. International Data Corporation (IDC) predicted that consumer online purchases in the fourth quarter of 1999 would total $7.1 billion in the USA, up from 64 percent from the same quarter in 1998. A post holiday online retailing survey conducted by Ernst & Young stated that 26 percent of those polled made an online purchase during the holidays, and that the number of women of women who shopped online outpaced men during the 1999 holiday season. The study, which polled 1,283 Internet users, found that, on average, online shoppers spent $1,225 on Internet purchase during the last 12 months, with 60 percent spending at least $500. The folks at E&Y expect total online revenues for 1999 to be between $25 -$30 billion. According to another study conducted by Media Matrix, the number of visitors to e-commerce sites was highest during the second week of December 1999. In 1998, the number of visitors to e-commerce sites was highest during the third week in December.
Leslie C. Wood is a freelance writer based in Philadelphia, PA. Her articles have been published in national magazines and newspapers as well as on many web sites. For more information, visit her web site at http://writer4u.com
Other Articles in this Category
Intro to the Internet and Web Pages (the VERY basics)
by Arnold Kim
The Meaning Behind url, http, .com etc.
by Davis Lingotti
Patience is a Virtue or is it? Ending the "World Wide Wait"
by Leslie Wood
Online Auctions: The Bargain Bonanza For Online Shoppers
by Leslie Wood
How to Search and Surf on the World Wide Web
by Leslie Wood
How to Make Money with Banner Advertising on your Website
by Arn
Intro to ADSL: the Autobahn of the Internet
by Leslie Wood
How to Create Your Own Web Page
by Grady Fox
How to Make Money with your Website
by Arn
Introduction to Making Money on the Internet (Individuals, Webmasters, Businesses)
by Arn
Other Sites
Storkin.com - Baby and
Pregnancy Tips and Discussion
AppShopper - iPhone Apps and Deals
Health Articles
Menopause
Symptoms
HIV/AIDS
Symptoms
West Nile
Symptoms
Diabetes
Symptoms
Pregnancy
Symptoms
Read other Articles -
click here.
|
